Ready For A “Crab-Santhemum”? We Go “Off The Menu” And Dive Into The “Secret” Swan Oyster Depot Menu In San Francisco! Seafood As Art!

Ready For Some “Seafood As Art?”

What you see above is an incredibly delicious plate of “seafood as art” – a “Crab-Santhemum!”

It’s just one of a number of wildly creative dishes from a legendary “hole in the wall” in San Francisco. I’ll explain exactly what it is and where my wife Alex and I got it – time to head to the bay area!

Welcome To The Swan Depot!

We are on Polk Street in San Francisco, a funky street filled with funky shops – and long lines form every single day at The Swan Deport…and Alex and I waited almost an hour to get in…so was it worth it?

Yes, this was the place where a man was walking his duck on the sidewalk outside…but it’s worth it, because this place is incredible!

As The San Francisco Chronicle reported:

“Swan Oyster Depot, like La Taqueria and House of Prime Rib, is an essential institution in San Francisco. This holy church of fresh seafood, this bastion of deliciousness, needs no introduction. The 18-seat counter has been around for more than 100 years and is beloved by locals and tourists alike.” 

Bizarre Foods Host Andrew Zimmern ate there, and as Eater SF wrote:

But of course. Zimmern waits in line to dine at this Polk Street standby, where his order is a half and half combination salad with crab and shrimp. “To me, this is Swan Oyster Depot, local seafood with louie dressing.” He also notes that “Swan is famous for having more items off the menu than on it,” and gets some “Sicilian Sashimi,” or crudo with capers, sea salt, and olive oil. Plus, “the oyster crackers are free!”

And as you read above, THIS is that “off the menu” dish known as “Sicilian Sashimi!”

As The San Francisco Chronicle reported:

“The Sicilian sashimi is more of an open secret — everyone knows about it. But it’s also not on the menu, so there you go. Thinly sliced raw salmon, tuna and scallops are served simply with a drizzle of olive oil, freshly cracked black pepper and some capers on top.” 

With that setup, let’s take a step back and pass the fresh seafood that stares out from the window…we got our seats at the tiny counter – and yes, there is only a counter with barely room to walk behind it – run by the son of the original owners…

Once inside, we perused the menu and read their introductory sign – it tells you all you need to know about this place:

We started with the freshest of Oysters, the only dish we ordered that was officially “on the menu”:

That’s right: just as you saw the “off the menu” item “Sicilian Sashimi” we ordered above, Alex did all of her research, so she knew about all of the secret menu items that weren’t on the board, and just kept ordering “off the menu” items like this:

The Crab-Santhemum!

Yes, it’s a plate of Dungeness Crab legs, arranged as a beautiful flower – it is presented as a work of art and you don’t want to eat it – but of course you do…but as terrific as this dish looks, it gets even better!

A regular sitting next to us was amazed by our ordering, and our Shucker told him he was sitting next to an “off the menu” pro!

Don’t Forget The “Crab Head” Dressing!

Not only is this gorgeous dish a secret, Alex also ordered the incredible dipping sauce that is perfect with it, and of course “off the menu” – made and served in a Crab head!

Normally, this dish is served with a side of Louie dressing – just as a Crab Louie would be….but guess what? The Swan Depot makes an “off the menu” olive oil vinaigrette with equal parts Dijon mustard and crab fat as the emulsifiers.


And they stir it all together right in the crab head, so you get all of the rich juices!

You can dip your crab into the head, and they also put the extra in a container and plop it down next to you – and guess what? The Chef gave our seating companion his own – and told him that Alex was a “pro” at the “off the menu” items!

We weren’t done yet with the secret menu – because up next is one of their most beautiful dishes, inspired by the incredible, edible egg!

Feast Your Eyes On “A Dozen Eggs”!

All you have to do is ask for a “dozen eggs” and here is what appears: thinly sliced raw scallops dotted with Sriracha, resting atop a shallow pool of ponzu. According to the Chronicle, the dish is inspired by a friend and regular Swan Depot customer who owns a sushi joint in the Richmond.

After so much secret stuff, we ended with one of their most popular items, something they are known for:

Beautiful smoked salmon draped lovingly over bread with capers…what a way to finish a meal!

I haven’t mentioned it, but the small staff working behind the counter, inducing the owner, are friendly, talkative and relaxed…they clearly love what they do – oh, and they don’t have a website to run – they just make food.

In fact, be sure to bring cash, because they don’t accept credit cards – look at how our bill was tallied!

We left with great memories, as well as two giveaways from the owner: a souvenir spouse (dried, just add water) and a photo of the gang…and what a great group they are!

Of course, you’ll need this great food after spending some time on “the rock!”

Yes, if you are in San Francisco, you need to take a ferry over to Alcatraz Island, which sits right in the middle of the bay…here is a tour of this infamous prison:

San Francisco is such an incredible city – and all of this incredible seafood made me want to make some!

How about a fried fish taco with homemade salsa and cabbage slaw!

I made this dish as part of my “52 In 22” cooking challenge – one new recipe from one of my cookbooks every week for an entire year!

See how this turned out by clicking here:

Perhaps the first week of my 2022 cooking challenge was a more upscale way to work with fish:

I made this “Fillet Of Sole” dish week one, with help from Vincent Price!

Click here to see how the Horror legend helped me!

If you enjoy these posts, why not subscribe and never miss out? It’s easy, and there are NO ads of any kind, just stuff I like…click on the main page and “follow” me on the upper right…

If you like the story, share it with friends on social media!

Let me know if you like the idea of eating sauce from a crab’s head!

Categories: Bite Eat Swallow, Bite! Eat! Repeat!, Eat This!, Fine Dining, Food, Food Pictures, Food Porn, Food Travel, Recipes, Restaurants, Travel, Wacky Food, World's Wildest Food

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

6 replies

  1. It looks like a great (though quite expensive) experience, John. But my scallops would have to be cooked, I’m afraid. 🙂
    Best wishes, Pete.

  2. Hi John, my what an interesting place. The duck pet is amazing. The food looks very exotic.


  1. Shucking Oysters Three Ways! “Angels On Horseback” For My “52 In 22 Cooking Challenge!” – Bite! Eat! Repeat!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: