It’s Nantucket Bay Scallop Season!
Behold. These are Nantucket Bay Scallops. Yes, they are about the size of a U.S. dime, but they are packed with a thousand dollars of flavor!
Let’s take a look at this “bivalve mollusk”: where they come from, how they are harvested and most importantly, how I plan to cook them for you!
Thirty miles off the Massachusetts coast, Nantucket Island is home to the world’s oldest sustainable bay scallop fishery. Nantucket Bay Scallops are a seasonal delicacy: just a few months in the winter, but I found them in New York and have made this dish three times in the past two months!
A local purveyor describes them this way:
“Nantucket’s isolated location and clear waters create a unique habitat that nurtures wild bay scallops, harvested in their second year after spawning, and are renowned for their subtle texture and distinct flavor.”
This is a photo I found online credited to Marine Science, Maria Michell Association. It’s a stunning shot of a Scallop in the water, waiting to be harvested.
The commercial harvesting season for Nantucket Bay Scallops extends from November through March , so I expect to make this dish again.
Thanks to Dorothy over at The New Vintage Kitchen, I had a terrific recipe to work from – let’s go!
Here are your ingredients:
1 lb. Nantucket Bay Scallops Flour for dusting
2 tbsp. olive oil
2 tbsp. butter or non-dairy butter 2 or 3 large shallots, minced
2/3 cup dry white wine
Another tablespoon or two of butter Salt and pepper
A handful of thawed frozen peas
Mashed potatoes are served underneath, so make a bath of those as well!
Clean the scallops, and soak for an hour in milk…it makes them cook better!
Pat them dry and dust them with flour. Season.
In a large, heavy skillet (not non-stick) heat over medium high and add the oil and butter. Once it is shimmering and the butter melted and no longer bubbling, add the shallots and sauté until they start to brown. I finished them and set them aside in a mug as you can see.
I then added some butter to the pan, got it hot and added the dusted scallops in a single layer – try not to crowd the pan, or they will steam and not color.
Here’s how I did it:
Cook for two minutes, without touching them, then turn if they are browned. I then stirred them up a bite and cooked for another two minutes, then I added the fresh peas, the wine and the caramelized shallots like this:
Literally bring the flavors together quickly and you are done!
Dorothy’s recipe ends with this last instruction and I love it:
“Serve over the mashed potatoes, and call everyone to the table. It will probably get quiet. Really quiet.”
She is right: they are just terrific: there’s a slight sweetness to these scallops, because they are small and packed with scallop flavor! The peas offer a nice bite and the shallots make them creamy…yes, I made VERY garlic mashed potatoes…you can serve a fresh salad on the side and you have a great meal!
Here’s a video of the entire process in a minute!
Dorothy shared a terrific recipe – slightly different as you will see – as well on her “New Vintage Kitchen” website…check it out here!
I love Scallops, but these one are truly special – normally I cook with the larger ones like this:
Same idea: sear them in a pan for this beautiful color – and I served them over a “zucchini – garlic succotash!” Here’s that recipe:
I love seafood – and I am also going to make one of my favorite stews again soon:
For now, if you are just too hungry to wait, you can click here for my most recent foray – I am really digging “Squid Stew” – see the recipe here:
I love the look, smell and taste of pan-seared scallops…and as part of 2022’s “52 In 22” cooking challenge, I made scallops three ways!
Little did I know when I started that one way would be BLUE!
Click here to see two great scallop recipes and one “turning blue” disaster!
I also cooked a “scalloped” dish, but it was an incredibly rich potato dish!
It was the “joy of cooking” to be sure!
Click here for the recipe!
If you enjoy these posts, why not subscribe and never miss out? It’s easy, and there are NO ads of any kind, just stuff I like to cook and eat – with recipes as well…click on the main page and “follow” me on the upper right…
If you like the story, share it with friends on social media! Thanks!
Categories: 52 In 22!, Bite Eat Swallow, Bite! Eat! Repeat!, Chef memoirs, Cookbooks, Eat This!, Fine Dining, Food, Food Travel, Recipes, Travel, Wacky Food, World's Wildest Food
Bite! Eat! Repeat! 
I’m so glad you loved this recipe too John! It’s my favorite way to eat the bays, especially my first ‘catch’ of the season. Nothing like it, and you did me proud! Thanks for all the links and for featuring one of my all-time favorite dishes.
PS I’ve already got my order in at the fish market for my birthday scallops, just a bit early!
Luckily for me, Citarella here in New York has an incredible fish counter and they sell them – we have had them 4 times so far this season and plan one more – which I will do specifically with your recipe – thanks for sharing it!
Wonderful! Lucky to have such an amazing source!
A fantastic post, John. When I read Nantucket scallops I immediately thought of Dorothy’s recipe and then you mentioned it.
Yes, I’ve been buying them for the last two months based on availability ility and when she posted her recipe I knew I had to add it to my post because it’s so different!
👍🏻😊
I love scallops and this recipe sounds delicious
I love scallops as well as Dorothy’s recipes plus who better than you, John to showcase one of Dorothy’s recipes such beautiful scallops you are both very lucky to have such a source I am envious 🙂